PCA BCO 14 Amendments Map Update

On Saturday, Iowa Presbytery voted to reject the proposed BCO amendments, bringing the vote tallies to 33-40 against on BCO 14-1 and 31-42 against on BCO 14-2. There are 6 Presbyteries left in the PCA which have not yet voted on these amendments. Interestingly, the votes in Iowa Presbytery were tied on both amendments (11-11). I've linked to the updated map below, and for anyone interested, I've also updated the spreadsheet with vote tallies, which you can access here.

WCF Sunday School Week 6: Of Creation

Week 6 of my Westminster Confession of Faith Sunday School class at Communion Presbyterian dealt with chapter 4 of the Confession: Of Creation. Below are links to the class handout, my lecture notes, and some further reading. Remember, all the material for the class can be accessed by clicking on the "Westminster Confession of Faith Sunday School Class" on the right hand side of this site.

Week 6 Handout
Week 6 Lecture Notes

Further Reading:

Did God Create in 6 Days? Joseph Pipa and David Hall, editors. [I cannot recommend this book highly enough. Every Presbyterian should own it and read it!]

WCF Sunday School Week 5: Of God's Eternal Decree

On week 5 of my Westminster Confession of Faith Sunday School class at Communion Presbyterian, I relied heavily upon Joseph Pipa's The Westminster Confession of Faith Study Book. His chapter on God's Eternal Decree is excellent. Below are links to the class handout, as well as my lecture notes.

Week 5 Handout
Week 5 Lecture Notes

WCF Sunday School Week 4: Of God and of the Holy Trinity

In the fourth class meeting of my Westminster Confession of Faith Sunday School class at Communion Presbyterian, we discussed Chapter 2 of the Confession: Of God and of the Holy Trinity. We had a good class discussion based on the handout which I've linked below. I used the handout as my lecture notes this time. Remember, all handouts, lecture notes, and other information regarding the class can be accessed by clicking on "Westminster Confession of Faith Sunday School Class" under "Labels" on the right hand side of the page.

Week 4 Handout/Lecture Notes

Full of the Holy Spirit: A Word Study

I don't often post my notes from the mid-week Bible study covering the Book of Acts I lead (maybe I should), but last week, as the study was ending, we had a discussion about what it means to be "full of the Holy Spirit". Stephen is said to be full of the Holy Spirit in Acts 7:55, and that is how the discussion arose. Since we were running out of time, I offered to prepare a brief study on what it means to be full of the Holy Spirit, for us to discuss this week. Below, I've linked to the handout we used to discuss that term. It was a good discussion, and I believe we all benefited from it.

Handout: A Word Study: "Full of the Holy Spirit" (Acts 7:55)

Six Observations on the PCA's Voting on BCO Amendments

I've been doing some analysis of the voting thus far on the (now failed) proposed amendments to the PCA Book of Church Order (BCO). As I have been creating the maps tracking the voting by the presbyteries, I have also been keep track of the vote tallies for each presbytery. If you are not the sort of person who is interested in number crunching and statistics, read no further. However, I think there are some interesting observations to be had from looking at the numbers. (NOTE: I have the vote tallies of 61 of the presbyteries. To date, 72 presbyteries have voted, so my data is not complete; however, I think it represents a large enough sample (84.72%) to make some observations.)

Observation 1: Abstentions matter! In 5 Presbyteries (Calvary, Chesapeake, Palmetto, Warrior and Western Carolina), the difference between BCO 14-1 passing or failing was less than the number of abstentions. The same is true in 4 Presbyteries for the voting on BCO 14-2 (same presbyteries as above, minus Chesapeake). For example, in Calvary Presbytery, the proposed amendment to BCO 14-1 passed by a vote of 37 to 31 and their were 10 abstentions. If those 10 men (or just 7 of those 10) had voted against the amendment, it would have been defeated.

Observation 2: Those same 5 presbyteries decided on 14-1 without a majority voting either way. There were 4 presbyteries that decided on 14-2 without a majority voting either way. For example, in Calvary Presbytery, 47.44% voted to approve 14-1 while 39.74% voted to reject it. There was not a majority vote for approving the amendment. The same is true of Chesapeake, Palmetto, Warrior, and Western Carolina Presbyteries for 14-1. (Chesapeake's percentages were: Approve: 45.83%, Reject: 47.92%. Palmetto: Approve: 34.55%, Reject: 43.64%. Warrior: Approve: 40%, Reject: 48%. Western Carolina: Approve: 0%, Reject: 17.07%.) For 14-2, the same presbyteries lacked a majority, except for Chesapeake which had 50.98% voting to reject.

Observation 3: The total number of votes from all presbyteries on 14-1 is 1,058 for, 1,167 against, 144 abstain. For 14-2 the numbers are 966 for, 1,221 against, 183 abstain. If all those voters had been at General Assembly last year, these amendments would have never gone to the Presbyteries in the first place. But, in fairness to those who were not able to attend GA, a lot of great opinion and analysis pieces dealing with these amendments have been written since then, as well.

Observation 4: There were more abstentions in presbyteries which rejected the amendments than in presbyteries which approved the amendments. The average abstention rate (# of Abstentions/Total # of Votes) for presbyteries approving 14-1 was 5.52%; whereas, the same rate for presbyteries rejecting 14-1 was 8.98%. For 14-2 the numbers are 5.63% and 8.53%, respectively. I'm not sure what this means, other than, perhaps if voters thought the amendment was going to fail, rather than be on the losing side of a vote, they simply abstained.

Observation 5: The average size of presbyteries (that is, the total of all voting members at the meeting of Presbytery which voted on the amendments) approving 14-1 and 14-2 was larger than the average size of the presbyteries rejecting 14-1 and 14-2. The average size of a presbytery approving 14-1 was 44.71 while the average size of a presbytery rejecting 14-1 was 35.03. For 14-2 the average sizes were 43.73 and 36.1, respectively. There are a lot of reasons why this may be. As noted in Observation 3, the raw total votes is clearly for rejecting the amendments. Why, then, do approving presbyteries have more voting members? It could be that those in favor of approving the amendments did a better job in those presbyteries of getting like-minded elders to Presbytery (the "rally the troops" factor). It could be that those presbyteries have a higher percentage of Assistant Pastors (see here: http://www.baylyblog.com/2009/04/reading-metro-ny-presbytery-minutes.html here: http://www.weswhite.net/2010/02/proposal-for-attaining-ruling/ and here: http://www.therulingelder.com/2010/02/over-at-johannes-weslianus-rev.html for more on Assistant Pastors in the PCA). It could simply be that those presbyteries which approved 14-1 and 14-2 have more congregations in them, on average. There are a lot of reasons why the size of the presbytery is larger in approving presbyteries, and without more data, all I can do is speculate.

Observation 6: What happened in Western Carolina Presbytery? (OK, that's not really an observation, but it is a question I have after looking at the numbers.) Those brothers get the award for most skewed vote in favor of abstention. The tally for 14-1 was 0 voting yea, 7 voting nay and 34 abstaining. For 14-2 the totals were 0, 6, and 35! Perhaps there was some procedural tactic I'm not aware of at work, but it makes me wonder: Why have the amendments on the docket in the first place if all you're going to do is abstain? Perhaps someone more familiar with what happened at Western Carolina can help me understand the situation.

If anyone is interested, I've posted a spreadsheet of the vote tallies, here: PCA BCO Statistics

Feel free to reach your own conclusions based on these numbers.

PCA BCO 14 Amendments Map Update

Heartland Presbytery has joined the ever-growing list of PCA Presbyteries that have rejected the proposed amendments to their Book of Church Order. I've updated the map, as seen below: